7 Common Objections to Selling Parts Online and Why They’re Holding You Back

You’re no stranger to the pressures of keeping the parts department running smoothly, meeting sales goals, and managing inventory. But with the rise of eCommerce, you’ve likely heard the buzz around selling parts online and wondered if it’s really worth the time and effort. But the truth is, selling parts online doesn’t have to be as complex or overwhelming as it seems.

Let’s break down some of the most common objections and why selling parts online could be the easiest and most profitable move you make.
 

“It’s too hard to sell parts online”

Many parts managers worry that selling parts online requires a tech background or specialized knowledge. But it doesn’t have to be. With the right tools, getting your parts listed online is simpler than you might think. You don’t need to be a tech expert to set up an online store. Platforms like RevolutionParts offer easy-to-use solutions that take the guesswork out of selling online.

Starting small is key. You can list your fast-moving parts first, then expand as you gain confidence. Taking small steps will build momentum, and soon you’ll be able to expand your offerings without feeling overwhelmed. It’s all about taking action, one part at a time.

“My customers don’t buy parts online”

You’re right. Anyone who’s buying parts online is taking their business to your competitors. It’s easy to assume that your customers aren’t interested, especially if they’ve always preferred to shop in person. But the reality is that buying habits are changing. People are increasingly turning to the internet to buy parts—whether it’s for basic maintenance, accessories, or DIY repairs.

Online auto parts sales in the U.S. more than tripled between 2016 and 2023—hitting over $35 billion in 2023, up roughly 50% compared to 2020 alone.

When a customer needs a replacement part, do you think they’ll wait for the next time they visit the dealership, or will they search online and make a purchase from a convenient source? With a well‑designed, user‑friendly website and an optimized inventory catalog, you can capture shoppers’ attention and make the buying process easy.

 

“I don’t have time”

If you’re like most parts managers, you can hardly fit your to‑do list in as it is… so where would you fit in online sales? Well, that’s the beauty of it. Your online business is like a dial that you can turn up or down depending on how much you want to grow. It may come as a surprise, but selling parts online doesn’t require extra hours or new staff. 

Most parts departments don’t need to hire additional help until they hit $50,000+ in monthly recurring revenue. 

By listing parts online, you’re creating a system that works for you 24/7. It’s like having an extra salesperson on the job, working while you sleep, with minimal ongoing effort from you.
 

“What if it doesn’t work?”

What if you put in the effort and it doesn’t pan out? Well, it might not. But if it’s going to work, it’s going to be with RevolutionParts and it’s going to require an all‑in attitude. Starting small and measuring success is the way forward. Parts managers who start selling online typically see incremental growth, and that’s where the magic happens.

Tracking results along the way lets you see what’s working and what’s not, so you can adjust as you go. The more you sell, the easier it gets. Your investment in the online store is a long‑term asset. Even if it feels slow at first, each sale contributes to your overall growth.

 

“The profit margins aren’t worth it”

Online sales come with slimmer profit margins than what you pull through your parts counter and service department. But  selling online isn’t about margins, it’s about the gross profit you generate from volume sales, the manufacturer incentives you unlock, and the global outlets for aging inventory.

You’ll be tapping into new, national markets without the overhead costs of a larger sales team or more in‑person foot traffic. Selling more parts at a higher volume can offset smaller margins, and many eCommerce platforms like RevolutionParts offer marketing tools that help you increase sales and boost your revenue.

 

“There are too many issues”

There are always challenges when trying something new, but winning requires taking risks. That doesn’t mean you should avoid the opportunity. Whether it’s managing inventory, dealing with returns, or setting up the website, these issues can be overcome with the right strategy and support.

Dealers using RevolutionParts’ smart fitment tools and accurate catalog data see up to 30% fewer returns than those who don’t.

Platforms like RevolutionParts are designed to handle these concerns for you. From inventory management to seamless customer support, these systems ensure that you’re not left to figure things out on your own. Plus, with easy catalog ingestion and automatic updates, you don’t have to worry about inaccurate listings or outdated products.

With the right tools in place, you can focus on growing sales and serving customers, while the platform takes care of the details that often slow dealerships down.

 

“I don’t know where to start”

Getting started can feel like the biggest hurdle. But once you choose a platform, like RevolutionParts, getting your inventory online is easier than you might think. Many tools provide step-by-step instructions, personalized support, and even pre-built web store templates to make the process smoother.

Start by selecting your top-selling parts, inputting your product information, and slowly expanding your offerings. And remember, you don’t need to do it all at once. The key is to take it step by step, monitor your progress, and adjust accordingly.

 

Taking the first step to online success

When you take the first step to selling parts online, you’ll find that the benefits far outweigh the challenges. Whether it’s reaching a larger audience, increasing your sales without additional overhead, or improving your bottom line, selling parts online is a smart and profitable move for any parts department.

You don’t need to do it alone. With the right tools, support, and strategy, you can easily expand your sales channels and position your department for success online. Start small, track your progress, and let the online sales work for you.

 Ready to See How Easy Selling Parts Online Can Be?

 Book a quick demo of RevolutionParts and learn how to boost sales, reach more customers, and simplify online parts selling

A Podcast Just for Parts People

Subscribe to Parts Pros Podcast for weekly 15-minute episodes where industry experts share real stories from the parts department, tips for success, how they overcome challenges, and why they love their work.

The Parts Manager’s Checklist to Mastering eBay

Subscribe for Future
Episodes, Updates &
Special Information

Featured Content

5 Reasons Selling Parts Online Is a Terrible Idea for Your Dealership

5 Reasons Selling Parts Online Is a Terrible Idea for Your Dealership

Look, selling parts online is not for everybody. Some dealerships enjoy the thrill of waiting ...
Aftermarket ROI Infographic

Aftermarket ROI Infographic

Unlock success with The Parts Marketing Playbook Every Manager Needs for effective marketing strategies and insights.
No results found.