What Do You Do When Your Dealership Hits a Wall?

One GM walked into a struggling dealership, took on a market full of bigger competitors, and helped quadruple the business.

Meet Nick Burch, General Manager of Lincoln of Bloomington and our guest on this episode of the Parts Pros Podcast.

You feel the pressure to grow Fixed Ops. But what happens when your team is already stretched thin? Your local competitors can sell parts for less than you can buy them. And the usual ways of bringing in more business aren't exactly working?

Do you hire more people? Spend more on advertising? Start chasing wholesale accounts?

Or do you find a completely different way to grow?

That's the situation Nick Burch walked into as the new Fixed Ops Director at Lincoln of Bloomington.

Five years later, the business had quadrupled.

First, let's talk about what Nick walked into.

Two service advisers. Five technicians. One parts guy. And someone handling shipping and receiving part-time. Not exactly a dream team for turning around a dealership.

Nick had come from running one of the largest Chrysler stores in the Upper Midwest. So walking into this operation was, in his words, a shock.

The store wasn't running efficiently. The service department needed work. And the parts department wasn't bringing in nearly enough business.
Nick Burch, GM, Lincoln of Bloomington

You can't outsell a dealer who buys parts cheaper than you do.

Nick wasn't particularly interested in spending his days fighting a losing battle.

Lincoln of Bloomington sits in the Twin Cities metro area. Plenty of potential customers... But also some monster wholesale competitors.

The kind of dealers buying parts by the truckload and selling them for less than Nick's dealership could purchase them.

And even if he could win a few accounts, there was still the usual wholesale baggage. Delivery demands. Phone calls. Returns. Experienced counter staff getting pulled away from the service drive.

Nick had a better idea: Instead of fighting over the same local wholesale customers, why not sell to people outside the market entirely?

That's when he decided to start selling parts online to:

  • Reach customers nationwide,
  • Adjust his prices to influence order volume,
  • And build another revenue stream without needing a fleet of delivery trucks.

"But I'm not making my usual markup."

And that's where a lot of Parts Departments get hung up.

You sell a part over the counter, you make a healthy markup. Sell that same part online, and you're competing on price with dealers across the country.

So why bother? Because a lower margin doesn't automatically mean less money.

Think about wholesale. You don't expect retail counter margins on every wholesale order. You're making money through volume.

15–20%

Nick says his online operation typically generates margins around 15% to 20%. But those orders don't require the same amount of counter time as a complicated mechanical wholesale request.

Online customers often know exactly what they need. Some already have the part number or VIN. Your team processes the order, gets the part shipped, and moves on.

Which would you rather have?

High %

Make the most margin possible on each individual sale, regardless of total gross.

More $

Make more gross profit through high-volume sales you wouldn't otherwise have gotten.

Margin percentage doesn't pay the bills. Gross profit dollars do.

And who's supposed to handle all these extra orders?

Nick's approach is pretty simple.

Don't give routine online orders to your most experienced counter guy.

That person needs to be helping your technicians, handling complicated parts requests, and keeping your service department moving.

Give straightforward order processing to someone who's comfortable working on a computer, communicating with customers, and handling shipping. It's also a great way to develop your next counter employee.

Here's where the math gets interesting.

More parts sales mean more gross profit. But what if they also helped you earn more on parts you were already buying?

That's exactly what's happening at Lincoln of Bloomington.

Ford rewards dealers for hitting certain purchasing targets. Nick's service department doesn't always generate enough volume to reach the highest tier on its own.

But once he added online orders to the mix, that changed.

That's on top of parts gross and shipping profit. Not a bad bonus for selling more parts.

Ford purchasing targets
Service department purchases + Online orders
+

In strong months, extra parts purchases help unlock another $10,000-15,000 in OEM incentives.

Illustrative. Bar lengths are not to scale.

So, what actually turned this dealership around?

Nick focused on:

  1. 01Improving service operations
  2. 02Getting customers in faster
  3. 03Building a stronger Fixed Ops team
  4. 04Creating a business model that made sense for his store.
  5. 05Adding another cash-positive revenue stream through online part sales.

He also recognized something a lot of dealerships overlook.

You don't have to choose between growing the service drive, local wholesale, and online sales. They're different customers. Different opportunities. Different ways to make money.

Five years after Nick took on a struggling operation, the business had quadrupled, and he went from Fixed Ops Director to General Manager.

Not bad for a store that started with one parts guy.

Think Your Dealership Is Hitting a Wall?

Here's how Nick Burch, GM at Lincoln of Bloomington, rebuilt a struggling operation, found new sources for gross profit, and created a business model that keeps growing.

Watch the full episode